NJCAA All- Americans/NIRA National Finalist
| 1963 | Bill Duckworth | Baseball | 1966 | Clifton Smith | Baseball | 1969 | Doug Ault | Baseball | ||
| 1970 | Doug Ault | Baseball | 1970 | Don Bounds | Baseball | 1971 | Larry Ratcliff | Baseball | ||
| 1972 | Bobby Falcon | Baseball | 1973 | JIm Brewster | Baseball | 1974 | Rufus Cook | Baseball | ||
| 1976 | Debra Thomas | W.Basketball | 1976 | Jim McWilliams | Baseball | 1977 | Mildred Hodge | W.Basketball | ||
| 1977 | Rosie Walker | W.Basketball | 1977 | Steve Winfield | Baseball | 1978 | Rosie Walker | W.Basketball | ||
| 1978 | Chris Campbell | Baseball | 1978 | Peggy Pope | W.Basketball | 1979 | Aroid Neal | M.Basketball | ||
| 1980 | Eric Smith | Baseball | 1983 | Ron Gideon | Baseball | 1983 | Dexter Shouse | M.Basketball | ||
| 1984 | Ron Gideon | Baseball | 1985 | Todd Haney | Baseball | 1986 | Ken Reese | Baseball | ||
| 1987 | Mark Brown | Baseball | 1988 | David Lowery | Baseball | 1990 | Angela Brown | W.Basketball | ||
| 1992 | Marc Albarado | Baseball | 2002 | Omar Thomas | M.Basketball | 2005 | Brandi Johnson | W.Basketball | ||
| 2006 | Josey Parker | Baseball | 2006 | Matt Smith | Rodeo | 2007 | Tilden Hooper | Rodeo | ||
| 2008 | Kim Edmonson | W.Basketball | 2008 | Tilden Hooper | Rodeo | 2009 | Matt Juengal | Baseball | ||
| 2009 | Jason Thomas | Rodeo | 2010 | Courtnee Davis | Volleyball | 2010 | Jason Thomas | Rodeo | ||
| 2010 | Josie Santos | Volleyball | 2011 | Josie Santos | Volleyball | 2013 | Bryce Barney | Rodeo | ||
| 2013 | Steven Campbell | Rodeo | 2014 | Kennedi Coleman | Volleyball | 2015 | Wyatt Denny | Rodeo | ||
| 2015 | Gannon Ivey | Rodeo | 2016 | Fulton Rutland | Rodeo | 2016 | Austin Sojka | Baseball | ||
| 2016 | Ana Oliveira | Volleyball | 2017 | Genesis Rivera | W.Basketball | 2017 | Logan Cook | Rodeo | ||
| 2017 | Abby Phillips | Rodeo | 2018 | Micheal Lawson | Baseball | 2018 | Logan Cook | Rodeo | ||
| 2018 | Travis Chapman | Rodeo | 2018 | Koby Radley | Rodeo | 2019 | Daylon Swearingen | Rodeo | ||
| 2019 | Logan Cook | Rodeo | 2019 | Tyler Johnson | Rodeo | 2019 | Macon Murphy | Rodeo | ||
| 2019 | Mikayla Ware | Volleyball | 2021 | Michael Womack | Rodeo | 2021 | Macon Murphy | Rodeo | ||
| 2021 | Kincade Henry | Rodeo | 2021 | Riley Rieken | Rodeo | 2021 | Gauge McBride | Rodeo | ||
| 2021 | Jayden Gould | Rodeo | 2021 | Kolt Dement | Rodeo | 2021 | Cody Deen | M.Basketball | ||
| 2021 | Seth Rustin | Rodeo | 2022 | Kolt Dement | Rodeo | 2022 | Gauge McBride | Rodeo | ||
| 2023 | Isaac Ingram | Rodeo | 2024 | Jonah Hinton | M.Basketball | 2025 | Jayden Broussard | Rodeo | ||
| 2025 | Awa Fane | W.Basketball | 2025 | Khoi Thurmon | M.Basketball | 2025 | CJ Worsham | M.Basketball |